Skip to content

Once You Know Something You Cannot Unknow It. That Is Why Smart People Make the Worst Explainers.

Reading Time: 5 minutes
Smart People Make the Worst

There is a specific kind of frustration that happens when someone very good at something tries to explain it to someone who is not. The expert speaks. The novice nods. Nothing lands. The expert tries again, more slowly, with more detail. Still nothing. The expert ends up privately concluding that the other person is simply not very bright.

The expert is wrong. The problem is not on the receiving end. It is on the transmitting end. And the smarter the expert, the worse the problem tends to be.

The Experiment That Measured It

In 1990, Elizabeth Newton was completing her PhD in psychology at Stanford. She designed a simple experiment that produced results so uncomfortable that Chip Heath and Dan Heath would later call it the best illustration of a cognitive bias they had ever seen.

Newton divided participants into two groups: tappers and listeners. Tappers were given a list of well-known songs, such as Happy Birthday and The Star-Spangled Banner, and asked to tap out the rhythm of each song on a table. Listeners had to identify the song from the tapping alone. Before the session, tappers were asked to predict what percentage of listeners would correctly identify their songs.

The tappers predicted fifty percent. The actual result was two and a half percent. Out of one hundred and twenty tapping sessions, listeners identified the correct song three times.

The tappers were not being overconfident about their tapping ability. They were being overconfident about something else entirely: their ability to imagine what it is like to hear tapping without hearing the song. Every time a tapper tapped, the full melody was playing inside their head. They could not turn it off. They had no mechanism for simulating what the sound meant to someone who could not hear what they were hearing.

This is not a minor miscalibration. It is a systematic failure that compounds with knowledge. The more you know, the more melodies are playing in your head, and the less you are able to hear what you sound like to someone who cannot hear them.

Amazon Finds

Weirdly Useful Things Under $25

Real stuff, real low prices. Amazon's best-kept budget finds, picked for everyday usefulness, not just novelty.

Browse the Finds
UNDER $25 AMAZON FINDS

The Name for What You Cannot Undo

The phenomenon had been observed informally for years before it was given a formal name. In 1989, economists Colin Camerer, George Loewenstein, and Martin Weber published a paper in the Journal of Political Economy titled “The Curse of Knowledge in Economic Settings.” They were studying how well-informed traders predicted the behavior of less-informed traders in a market, and they found a consistent pattern: the informed traders systematically overestimated how much the uninformed traders knew.

They called it the curse of knowledge. The word “curse” is deliberate. It is not simply a gap in information. It is an inability to reconstruct a prior mental state. Once you understand something, the state of not understanding it becomes genuinely inaccessible. You cannot perform that regression accurately no matter how hard you try.

The curse of knowledge is asymmetric. It only flows one direction. The novice can imagine becoming an expert. The expert cannot accurately imagine being a novice again. The knowledge does not just add to what you know; it rewrites how the subject feels.

Steven Pinker devotes substantial attention to the curse of knowledge in The Sense of Style, specifically in the context of why educated people write so badly. His argument is precise: academics and professionals are not bad writers because they lack intelligence. They are bad writers because they have too much knowledge and no reliable way to simulate what their sentences look like to someone who does not share it. They omit definitions because the terms feel obvious. They skip steps because the steps feel automatic. They mistake fluency for clarity.

Why Expertise Makes This Worse

The expert blind spot is not a fixed quantity. It scales. The more deeply someone knows a subject, the more completely the state of not knowing it has been overwritten. A beginner programmer still remembers what it felt like to stare at a syntax error without knowing what it meant. A twenty-year veteran does not. The memory has not simply faded; it has been replaced by automaticity so complete that the error is now invisible before it is even processed consciously.

This is why the most experienced person in a room is often the least useful person to explain something to a newcomer. They are not less intelligent. They are more cursed. Their knowledge is deeper, more encoded, more automatic, and therefore further from the surface where the novice currently lives.

The Heath brothers make this point sharply in Made to Stick: expertise is precisely what makes the curse of knowledge dangerous rather than merely inconvenient. The expert has not just forgotten what it felt like to not know. The expert has acquired a new perceptual system that processes the domain differently, at a level of abstraction that makes the basics feel redundant to state.

The beginner needs the basics stated. The expert finds them too obvious to say. This gap is not a failure of goodwill. It is a structural consequence of how knowledge physically reorganizes cognition over time.

Daniel Kahneman’s work in Thinking, Fast and Slow gives the underlying mechanism: expertise moves decisions from the slow, deliberate System 2 to the fast, automatic System 1. What once required conscious effort becomes reflex. What once had to be explained step by step now arrives as a single intuition. The expert can no longer narrate the steps because the steps have been compressed into a single perception. Asked to explain, they produce the output of a process they can no longer see from the outside.


What You Can Do About a Curse

You cannot un-know what you know. Newton’s tappers could not stop hearing the song. Camerer’s traders could not stop knowing the market information. Pinker’s academics cannot stop knowing what their jargon means. The cognitive bias is structural, not attitudinal. Wanting to explain clearly is not the same as being able to.

What does help is not trying to un-know, but building a proxy for what not knowing looks like. Specific examples over abstract principles. Concrete images over technical vocabulary. A story that traces the path from confusion to understanding rather than a summary that starts at the conclusion. These are not simplifications. They are reconstructions of a cognitive journey the expert has already made and can no longer remember making.

The expert blind spot cannot be eliminated. It can be audited. The useful question is not “does the audience know what I know?” The useful question is “what did I need to see, before I understood this, that I no longer notice I needed?”

That question is uncomfortable. It requires imagining a version of yourself that no longer exists. But it is the only question that actually transfers knowledge rather than demonstrating it.

Now you know. The question is what you do with it.
Marco Bellinari

Want to understand yourself a little better? These books will help.

Sources

Marco Bellinari

A Note from Marco Bellinari

Thank you for reading. Every fact in this article is documented and sourced. You will find the references at the bottom if you want to dig further. I hope it surprised you at least once. That is always the intention.

I would love to hear your thoughts. Follow Econopass on social media and share your reaction hereafter as a social comment. And if you do not want to miss the next story, hit follow. There is always another forgotten truth waiting to be told.

📖 Read More
Set as Preferred Source
Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links. This means we may earn a commission if you click on a link and make a purchase at no extra cost to you. This applies to featured Amazon products or any other Econopass's partners.